PIs: Paolo Leonardi, Sebastiano Moruzzi
AIs: Massimilano Carrara, Walter Cavini, Annalisa Coliva, Elisabetta Lalumera, Vittorio Morato, Eva Picardi, Elisabetta Sacchi, Marco Santambrogio, Marina Sbisà , Giuseppe Spolaore, Giorgio Volpe.
PhD and Master students: Delia Belleri, Carlotta Capuccino, Daria Mingardo, Alessia Marabini, Andrea Marino, Favio Minocchio, Sara Neva, Filippo Ferrari, Antonio Ferro, Eugenio Orlandelli, Michele Palmira, Iryna Sivertsava.
External researchers: Francesco Berto, Richard Dietz, Daniele Mezzadri, Dag Westerståhl
Title of the project: Predication, Context and Relativism
Scientific aim of the project
The project in Philosophy of Language will focus on the problem of predication, on contextualism and minimalism in semantics and on whether the concept of truth requires a relativistic treatment. More specifically it will consider:
Methodology
In the second semester of the academic year 2008-2009, the section of Philosophy of Language group based in Bologna will hold twice a week a reading group and a research seminar until end of June (reading list). The research seminar will host research papers by both members of the group and invited speakers (list). The entire group will meet with a flexible cadence in intensive one or two-days seminars where it will be discussed the papers of some of the members.
In February 2010 the group will host a major event on truth-relativism (programme and dates tba).
Expected results
Argument Templates used by semantic minimalists
Arguments against semantic minimalism
no explanatory role of compositionality for understanding Szabo&King(2005)
Replies
intuitions track semantic content -
Stanley&Szabo(2000) for quantified sentences; Stanley(2000, 2002a, 2002b), Szabo(2001)
Replies
Argument Templates used by semantic skeptic
Against: Stanley(2000, 2002a, Szabo&King(2005)
Arguments against semantic skepticism
3 models Szabo&King(2005)
Weak pragmatic effect (semantic role of context): context affect what is communicated by affecting content via resolution of context-sensitive elements in the sentence uttered.
Strong pragmatic effect (pragmatic role of context): context affect what is communicated over and abov semantic content
The project in Philosophy of Language will focus on the problem of predication, on contextualism and minimalism in semantics and on whether the concept of truth requires a relativistic treatment.
For futher details, please see here.